Reflections on “literary awareness in Wei and Jin Dynasties”

Literary awareness in the Wei and Jin Dynasties (Wei Chao 魏朝CE 220–265; Jin Chao 晋朝CE 265–420), as first proposed by Suzuki Torao, is not a “scientific” ... Skiptomaincontent Advertisement SearchSpringerLink Search AbstractLiteraryawarenessintheWeiandJinDynasties(WeiChao魏朝CE220–265;JinChao晋朝CE265–420),asfirstproposedbySuzukiTorao,isnota“scientific”argument.Fromtherelationshipsbetween“practicalism”and“literaryawareness”aswellas“individualism”and“lyricliterature”intheHan(HanChao汉朝BCE206–CE220)andWeiDynasties,itcanbeseenthatthefundamentaldriveofmedievalliteraturewasthesocialchangestakingplaceduringthesedynasties,theemergenceoftheliteratiasasocialstratum,andtheirattitudetowardsliterature.Theconceptof“literaryawarenessintheWeiandJinDynasties”cannotdescribetheliterarydevelopmentinmedievalChina.AsitmisunderstandstheessentialcharacteristicsinthedevelopmentofChineseliterature,itshouldbediscarded.摘要日本学者铃木虎雄首倡的“魏晋文学自觉说”并不是一个科学的论断。

“汉代文学自觉说”是对“魏晋文学自觉说”的一个有力挑战,从汉魏以来“功利主义”与“文学自觉”、汉人的“个体意识”与抒情文学的关系来看,促进汉魏以来中国中古文学发展变化的根本原因是秦汉社会制度的变革、文人阶层的出现及其特殊的文化心态,以及他们对于文学的基本态度。

以此为基础,可以清晰地看到从汉到唐的中国文学的演变轨迹。

“魏晋文学自觉说”不能全面地描述中国中古文学的发展过程,它影响了我们对于中国文学发展规律和本质特征的认识,因而在中国中古文学研究中不适宜使用“文学自觉”这一概念。

Thisisapreviewofsubscriptioncontent,accessviayourinstitution. Accessoptions Buysinglearticle InstantaccesstothefullarticlePDF. 34,95€ PriceincludesVAT(Singapore)Taxcalculationwillbefinalisedduringcheckout. RentthisarticleviaDeepDyve. LearnmoreaboutInstitutionalsubscriptions ReferencesCaoZhi曹植.“YuYangDezushu”与杨德祖书(LettertoYangDezu).In:ZhaoYouwen赵幼文,ed.1984.Caozhijijiaozhu曹植集校注(NotesonCaoZhi’sWorkCollection).Beijing:RenminWenxueChubanshe. GoogleScholar  ChunqiuZuozhuanJijieXianggongErshisinian春秋左传集解·襄公二十年(CollectedNotesonSpringandAutumnAnnalsandZuoCommentaryonChunqiu[withreferenceto]“Year20ofEmperorXiang”),1997,Shanghai:ShanghaiRenminChubanshe.CuiBao崔豹(1984)Gujinzhu古今注(CommentariesonAntiquityandToday),Vol.7,Hangzhou:ZhejiangRenminChubanshe. GoogleScholar  FeiZhengang费正纲(1993)Quanhanfu全汉赋(Rhyme-proseinHanDynasty),Beijing:BeijingDaxueChubanshe. GoogleScholar  GeHong葛洪(1985)Xijingzaji西京杂记(MiscellaneaoftheWesternCapital).Beijing:ZhonghuaShuju. GoogleScholar  GongKechang龚克昌(1981)“LunHanfu”论汉赋(Onrhyme-proseoftheHanDynasty).Wenshizhe文史哲(Literature,History,Philosophy).GongKechang龚克昌(1988)“Hanfu—wenxuezijueshidaideqidian”汉赋—文学自觉时代的起点(Rhyme-proseintheHanDynasty-thebeginningofliteraryawarenessAge).In:Wenshizhe文史哲(Literature,History,Philosophy).GongKechang龚克昌(1990)“Hanfu—YunwenshiShangdeQipa”汉赋—韵文史上的奇葩(Rhyme-proseinHanDynasty-thepreciousflowerinrhymedarticlehistory).In:HanfuYanjiu汉赋研究(Rhyme-proseintheHanDynastyResearch).Jinan:ShandongYishuChubanshe. GoogleScholar  GuoMaoqian郭茂倩(1979)Yuefushiji乐府诗集(ACollectionofBalladPoetry).Vol.43.Beijing:ZhonghuaShuju. GoogleScholar  GuoShaoyu郭绍虞(1979)Zhongguowenxuepipingshi中国文学批评史(ChineseLiteratureCriticalHistory).Shanghai:ShanghaiGujiShudian. GoogleScholar  HanshuYangxiongzhuan汉书·杨雄传(HistoryofHanDynasty[withreferenceto]“BiographyofYangXiong”). HanshuWangbaozhuan汉书·王褒传(HistoryofHanDynasty[withreferenceto]“BiographyofWangBao”). HouhanshuZhanghengLiezhuan后汉书·张衡列传(HistoryoftheLaterHanDynasty[withreferenceto]“BiographyofZhangHeng”).HongXingzu洪兴祖(1989)Chucibuzhu楚辞补注(SupplementaryNotesfortheElegiesofChu).Beijing:ZhonghuaShuju. GoogleScholar  JinshuRuanjizhuan晋书·阮籍传(BookofJinDynasty[withreferenceto]“BiographyonRuanJi”).LiBinghai李炳海(2001)Huangzhongdalvzhiyin—gudaicifuwenbendechanshi黄钟大吕之音—古代辞赋的文本阐释(NiceMusic—theTextualAnalysisoftheAncientRhyme-prose).Changchun:JilinRenminChubanshe. GoogleScholar  LiZehou李泽厚(1981)Meidelicheng美的历程(ThePathofBeauty).Beijing:WenwuChubanshe. GoogleScholar  LuXun鲁迅(1981)“Weijinfengdujiwenzhangyuyaojijiudeguanxi”魏晋风度及文章与药及酒的关系(TherelationshipofgraceinWeiandJinDynastiesandarticlewithmedicineandliquor).In:Luxunquanji鲁迅全集(LuxunWorkCollection).Vol.3.Beijing:RenminWenxueChubanshe. GoogleScholar  ShisanjingZhushuLiliZhengyi十三经注疏·礼礼正义(TheThirteenClassics,AnnotatedandExplicated[withreferenceto]“OnLiliZhengyi”),1999.Beijing:BeijingDaxueChubanshe. ShisanjingZhushuLiliZhengyiYueji十三经注疏·礼礼正义·乐记(TheThirteenClassics,AnnotatedandExplicated[withreferenceto]“OnLiliZhengyi”and“Treatiseonmusic”),1999.Beijing:BeijingDaxueChubanshe. ShisanjingZhushuZhouliZhushu十三经注疏·周礼注疏(TheThirteenClassics,AnnotatedandExplicated[withreferenceto]“OnritesofZhou”),1999.Beijing:BeijingDaxueChubanshe.SunMingjun孙明君(1999)Sancaoyuzhongguoshishi三曹与中国诗史(ThreeCaosandtheHistoryofChinesePoem).Beijing:ChinghuaDaxueChubanshe. GoogleScholar  SuzukiTorao铃木虎雄(1989)Zhongguoshilunshi中国诗论史(ChinesePoemHistory)(inChinese,trans.XuZong).Nanning:GuangxiRenminChubanshe. GoogleScholar  TaoYuanming陶渊明(1979)“Wuliuxianshengzhuan”五柳先生传(BiographyofMr.Wuliu).In:LuChinli逯钦立,ed.TaoYuanmingji陶渊铭集(WorkCollectionofTaoYuanming).Beijing:ZhonghuaShuju. GoogleScholar  WangLiqi王利器(1980a)Wenxindiaolongjiaozheng文心雕龙校正(VerificationfortheLiteraryMindandtheCarvingofDragons).Shanghai:ShanghaiGujiChubanshe. GoogleScholar  WangLiqi王利器(1980b)Yanshijiaxunjijie颜氏家训集解(AdmonitionsofMasterYan).Shanghai:ShanghaiGujiChubanshe. GoogleScholar  WangZhongling王钟陵(1988)Zhongguozhonggushigeshi中国中古诗歌(ChinaMedievalPoemHistory).Nanjing:JiangsuJiaoyuChubanshe. GoogleScholar  WangYunxi王运熙,YangMing杨明,eds.(1996)Weijinnanbeichaowenxuepipingshi魏晋南北朝文学批评史(LiteraryCriticalHistoryofWei,Jin,SouthernandNorthernDynasties).WuChengxue吴承学(2002)ZhongguoGudaiwentiXingtaiYanjiu中国古代文体形态研究(ResearchonAncientChineseLiteratureStyle).Guangzhou:ZhongshanDaxueChubanshe. GoogleScholar  WangXianqian王先谦,ed.(1986a)“ZhuangziTianxiapian”庄子·天下篇(ZhuangziTheWorld)In:Zhuangzijijie庄子集解(CollectedNotesonZhuangzi),Zhuzijicheng诸子集成(CollectedWorksofZhuzi),Vol.3.Shanghai:ShanghaiShudian.WangXianqian王先谦(1986b)XunziRuoxiao荀子·儒效(XunziRuxiao).In:Zhuangzijijie庄子集解(CollectedNotesonZhuangzi),Zhuzijicheng诸子集成(CollectedWorksofZhuzi),Vol.2.Shanghai:ShanghaiShudian. GoogleScholar  YuanXingpei袁行霈,ed.(1999)Zhongguowenxueshi中国文学史(ChineseLiteraryHistory),Vol.2.Beijing:GaodengJiaoyuChubanshe. GoogleScholar  ZhanFurui詹福瑞(1998)“Wenshi,JingshengdeWenshihuayuWenxuedeZijue”文士、经生的文士化与文学的自觉(TheliteratitrendofJingshengandawarenessofliterature).Hebeixuekan河北学刊(AcademicMagazineinHebei),Vol.4.ZhanFurui詹福瑞(2000)“ConghandairenduiQuYuandePipingkanHandaiwenxuedeZijue”从汉代人对屈原的批评看汉代文学的自觉(FromthecriticsofHanPeopleonQuYuantoSeetheAwarenessofLiteratureinHanDynasty).WenyililunYanjiu(ArtTheoreticResearch),Vol.5.ZhangShaokang张少康(1996)“LunwenxuedeDuliheZijuefeiziWeijinshi”论文学的独立和自觉非自魏晋始(OntheindependenceandawarenessofliteraturenotstartingfromWeiandJin).Beijingdaxuexuebao北京大学学报(PekingUniversityAcademicPaper),Vol.2.ZhangShaokang张少康(1984)Wenfujishi文赋集释(CollectedNotestotheRhyme-proseonWriting).Shanghai:ShanghaiGujiChubanshe. GoogleScholar  ZhangPeiheng章培恒,ed.(1996)Zhongguowenxueshi中国文学史(ChineseLiteraryHistory).Shanghai:FudanDaxueChubanshe. GoogleScholar  ZhaoMinli赵敏俐(1994)“LunBangudeyongshishiyuwenrenwuyanshifazhanchengshuwenti”论班固的咏诗史与文人五言诗发展成熟问题(AnalysisonBanGu’sYongshipoemandthepenta-syllabicPoemmaturity).Beifangluncong北方论从(ForumofNorthern).Vol.1.DownloadreferencesAuthorinformationAuthorsandAffiliationsChinaPoetryResearchCenter,CapitalNormalUniversity,Beijing,100089,ChinaZhaoMinliAuthorsZhaoMinliViewauthorpublicationsYoucanalsosearchforthisauthorin PubMed GoogleScholarCorrespondingauthorCorrespondenceto ZhaoMinli.AdditionalinformationTranslatedfromZhongguoshehuikexue中国社会科学(SocialSciencesinChina),2005,(2):155–167byPengYixia,DepartmentofForeignLanguages,BeihangUniversity(BUAA)AboutthisarticleCitethisarticleZhao,M.Reflectionson“literaryawarenessinWeiandJinDynasties”. Front.Lit.Stud.China1,351–377(2007).https://doi.org/10.1007/s11702-007-0017-3DownloadcitationIssueDate:July2007DOI:https://doi.org/10.1007/s11702-007-0017-3SharethisarticleAnyoneyousharethefollowinglinkwithwillbeabletoreadthiscontent:GetshareablelinkSorry,ashareablelinkisnotcurrentlyavailableforthisarticle.Copytoclipboard ProvidedbytheSpringerNatureSharedItcontent-sharinginitiative KeywordsliteraryawarenessoftheWeiandJinDynastiesliteraryawarenessoftheHanDynastyutilitarianismliteraryawarenessindividualconsciousnesslyricliterature关键词魏晋文学自觉说汉代文学自觉说功利主义文学自觉个体意识抒情文学 Accessviayourinstitution Accessoptions Buysinglearticle InstantaccesstothefullarticlePDF. 34,95€ PriceincludesVAT(Singapore)Taxcalculationwillbefinalisedduringcheckout. RentthisarticleviaDeepDyve. LearnmoreaboutInstitutionalsubscriptions Advertisement